The short answer
Most meniscus tears give you time to try physiotherapy or rest first. Root tears and bucket handle tears are different. A root tear cuts off the meniscus's whole shock-absorbing function and can lead to osteoarthritis if it's left untreated. A bucket handle tear gets harder to repair the longer it stays out of place. On Pathway's PGA of Canada podcast series, orthopaedic sports surgeon Dr. Jihad Abouali said these are tears he recommends treating surgically fairly urgently rather than waiting to see if they settle.
What the meniscal roots are
The meniscus is a ring-shaped cushion inside the knee. Dr. Abouali explained that each meniscus has two points where it anchors directly into the bone of the shinbone (tibia). Those anchor points are the meniscal roots.
What happens when a root tears
When the root tears, the ring loses its anchor. Dr. Abouali said a torn root means you lose the entire function of that meniscus, its shock-absorber effect. Without that cushioning, the knee is more exposed, and he said these tears can lead to osteoarthritis if left untreated. When he talked about delaying treatment, he added that arthritis can set in “quite quick” after an untreated root injury.
Why root tears are easy to miss
Dr. Abouali noted that root tears can be difficult to diagnose without an MRI. That's one reason imaging is part of the usual workup for knee pain. An X-ray shows the overall health of the joint and the bone, and an MRI gives a three-dimensional view of the meniscus that shows where a tear is and whether any tissue has moved. When an MRI shows a root tear, he recommends surgery fairly urgently.
Bucket handle tears: the other one not to sit on
A bucket handle tear is a large tear where a big piece of meniscus flips out of place. Dr. Abouali included it with the unstable, displaced tears that don't really improve without surgery, and that he treats surgically from the start. A displaced flap of tissue is also the kind of tear that tends to cause locking and catching. See meniscus tear symptoms for what those feel like.
Timing matters here for a different reason than with root tears. Dr. Abouali explained that the longer you wait, the more likely the tear is to progress, and the harder it is to put the flap back in place and repair it. He said these are typically tears he'd want to fix within six weeks.
How these tears are treated
Both are treated with knee arthroscopy, a minimally invasive procedure where a small camera and instruments go in through two small keyhole incisions. For a root tear, Dr. Abouali said the treatment is a repair, which means stitching the meniscus back rather than trimming it away. You can read more about the procedure on the meniscal repair page.
Knee arthroscopy is day surgery. Dr. Abouali described patients arriving an hour or two before the procedure, having either a general anaesthetic or a spinal anaesthetic (numb from the waist down), a procedure of about 15 to 30 minutes, then about an hour in the recovery room before going home.
What recovery looks like after a root repair
A repair takes longer to recover from than a cleanup (partial meniscectomy), because the stitched meniscus needs time to heal. Dr. Abouali said a root repair falls on the longer side of recovery: crutches for a short period, then a longer physiotherapy period, with about four to six months before returning to sport. For meniscal repairs generally, he described the first four to six weeks as basic stretching and light strengthening before progressing.
His rehab approach has a clear order: bring swelling and inflammation down, restore range of motion with stretching, then a progressive strengthening program built around your sport. Going into surgery as strong as possible (“prehab”) makes that recovery easier. More on timelines in meniscus surgery recovery time and knee arthroscopy recovery time.
The goal: keeping your own knee
Dr. Abouali called these joint-preserving surgeries. The aim is a return to full capacity, with no pain, no swelling and good power in the joint. Everyone progresses at a slightly different rate, but the goal is to get you back to your original form and function. Repairing a root tear while it can still be repaired is part of protecting the knee from the arthritis an untreated root tear can lead to.
What Dr. Abouali said on the podcast
“If you've torn your meniscus root, you lose the entire function of that meniscus, which is a shock absorber effect.”
“They can be a little bit difficult to diagnose without an MRI.” , on root tears
“So those are typically tears we'd want to fix within six weeks.” , on bucket handle tears
Watch this part of the episode
In this 2-minute clip, Dr. Abouali explains meniscal root tears and why they shouldn't wait. In the full episode, root tears start at 15:19. Why delaying treatment matters, including root and bucket handle tears, starts at 33:35. The episode is part of Pathway's PGA of Canada series.
Frequently asked questions
What is a meniscus root tear?
A tear at one of the two points where the meniscus anchors into the shinbone. Dr. Abouali said it causes the meniscus to lose its entire shock-absorbing function.
Does a meniscus root tear need surgery?
Dr. Abouali recommends surgery fairly urgently when an MRI shows a root tear, because the meniscus loses its function and the tear can lead to osteoarthritis if left untreated.
How is a root tear diagnosed?
With an MRI. Dr. Abouali noted these tears can be difficult to diagnose without one.
How long is recovery after a meniscus root repair?
Dr. Abouali described it as one of the longer recoveries: crutches for a short time and a longer physiotherapy period, with about four to six months before returning to sport.
What is a bucket handle meniscus tear?
A large tear where a piece of the meniscus flips out of place. Dr. Abouali said these don't improve without surgery, and that he typically wants to fix them within six weeks.
Source: The Golfer's Knee: Managing Pain and Performance, Episode 3 of the PGA of Canada x Pathway Surgery series, recorded November 1, 2026, with Dr. Jihad Abouali and host Nino Nikolovski. Clinical statements are Dr. Abouali's, as said on the episode. This article is for general education and isn't medical advice. Speak with a qualified healthcare provider about your own symptoms and treatment options. See our editorial policy.